e-newsletter client login
articles and presentations
financial calculators
record retention
tax news
useful site links

Join our mailing list

We publish an e-newsletter that includes the latest news and tax alerts. To subscribe, enter your email address below:

Lack of Contemporaneous Written Acknowledgement Nixes Donation
Grossman St. Amour CPAs PLLC
April 2017

For more information about cash and non-cash charitable donations, contact Theresa M. Morgan, CPA, Tax Supervisor at 315.701.6336 or tmorgan@gsacpas.com.

In a case that provides a lesson to anyone donating property to charity for which a deduction of more than $500 is claimed – get proof in writing and get it at the time you donate the property.  After-the-fact substantiation, no matter how convincing, is not acceptable under the tax law to support a deduction.

Case in point: The Tax Court, in Izen, Jr. v. Commissioner, 148 TC No. 5, found that a failure to follow the substantiation rules for donation of an aircraft precluded a taxpayer from claiming a deductions. The taxpayer’s evidence of donation did not satisfy the substantiation requirements, which are heightened for donations of vehicles, including aircrafts.

The taxpayer was assessed a deficiency on his federal income tax return for the year at issue. He then filed an amended return on which he claimed that he had donated a 50 percent interest in an aircraft to a tax-exempt historical society.  His interest in the plane was appraised at $340,000, and he claimed a charitable contribution deduction in that amount.

The Tax Court observed that under Code Sec. 170(f)(12), contributions of used vehicles, including airplanes, whose claimed value exceeds $500, must satisfy special substantiation requirements. A taxpayer must obtain a contemporaneous written acknowledgment and include the acknowledgment with his or her return. Further, if the donee has not sold the vehicle or aircraft, the donee must certify the intended use or improvement to the property, among other requirements. Additionally, the donee must provide the IRS with a copy of the acknowledgment. The IRS developed Form 1098-C for this purpose.

The court found that the taxpayer did not include the requisite copy of Form 1098-C with his amended return, nor did the IRS receive the form from the historical society related to the taxpayer’s donation of the aircraft.

Although the taxpayer did include a copy of a letter to the IRS that was from the historical society thanking him for the donation, the court found that the letter failed to satisfy the contemporaneous written acknowledgement requirements. The letter failed to include the name and taxpayer identification number of the donor, among other items.

The court also rejected the taxpayer’s purported deed of a gift as satisfying the contemporaneous written acknowledgment requirement. The “aircraft donation agreement” did not meet the statutory requirements for a contemporaneous written acknowledgment. Like the letter, the deed failed to include the taxpayer identification number of the donor. The deed also did not include a certification of intended use.

For more information about cash and non-cash charitable donations, contact our office at 315.424.1120 or tkiesa@gsacpas.com.

back to articles & presentations



Grossman St. Amour CPAs PLLC
110 West Fayette Street, One Lincoln Center, Suite 900 • Syracuse, NY 13202
T 315.424.1120   F 315.422.0829   info@gsacpas.com
Privacy Policy

| About Us | Our Team | Firm News | Community Involvement | Associations/Memberships | Client Testimonials | Accounting & Auditing Services | Audit & Attest Engagements | Financial Statement Preparation | Bookkeeping | Internal Control Review | Fraud Examination & Deterrence | Consulting Services | Business Formation & Valuation | Financial Benefits & Retirement Planning | Merger, Acquisition & Succession Planning | Management Consulting | Real Estate Planning | Technology Consulting | Tax Services | Income Tax Return Preparation | Payroll & Sales Tax Return Preparation | Tax Planning for Businesses | Tax Planning for Individuals | IRS and State Tax Audit Representation  | Industries Served  | Affordable Housing | Construction & Real Estate | Employee Benefit Plans | Equestrian Businesses | Fire Districts Government / Municipalities | Medical Practices & Healthcare | Not-For-Profit | Public School Districts | Manufacturing and Retail Distribution | Resources | Articles & Presentations | Financial Calculators | Record Retention Guidelines | Tax News | Useful Site Links | Career Opportunities | Benefits | Employee Testimonials | Contact Information | Directions